Great Nicobar Project: Navy Chief Admiral Krishna Swaminathan on Monday, November 16, said the Great Nicobar Project could give India a major strategic advantage because of its location near the Malacca Strait. Speaking at the National Security Summit 3.0 in New Delhi, he said this location could help India maintain a stronger position over important international shipping routes.
“It’s an extremely important waterway, and there’s absolutely no doubt that having a capability close to that waterway gives you a significant strategic advantage… It would enable us to dominate the sea lanes as well as the Malacca Strait,” Navy Chief said.
Malacca Strait And China’s Presence in The Indian Ocean
The Malacca Strait connects the Indian Ocean with Southeast Asia, the South China Sea and the Pacific Ocean. It’s one of the important routes for international trade. Swaminathan said around 120,000 to 150,000 ships operate in the Indian Ocean region every year, and many of them pass through this waterway.
Ireland Police Buy Israeli-Made Anti-Drone Systems Despite Government Ban on Defence Purchases
“The Malacca Strait is a very important waterway. It connects the Indian Ocean region with Southeast Asia, the South China Sea, and the Pacific Ocean. A large amount of global trade passes through the Malacca Strait. We have something like 120,000 to 150,000 ships operating in the Indian Ocean region, and many of them funnel through the Malacca Strait, one way or the other,” he added.
He also said the Indian Navy keeps track of every ship entering the Indian Ocean Region (IOR). China has maintained an almost continuous presence in these waters since 2008, but he said ships involved in legitimate business are welcome.
“China has been present in the IOR on an almost permanent basis since September or October 2008. China’s presence in the IOR is not new to us. China can make its own sovereign decisions. We believe in freedom of navigation, and the sea belongs to the global commons. Anybody who comes here for legitimate business is welcome,” he said.
Swaminathan added that the Navy is closely watching the growing number of Chinese ships. He said their presence would become a concern only if they take part in activities that are not allowed.
“Their presence might become a concern for us if China does something that it ought not to do. However, we continue to monitor Chinese ships in the region. The number of Chinese ships is increasing, and their presence is growing. We closely monitor China’s activities,” he stated.
He also clarified that keeping track of ships isn’t simply an attempt to counter China. It’s part of the Navy’s responsibility to protect India’s interests.
“We are not trying to counter China simply for the sake of countering it. But, in our national interest, as the Navy of a responsible nation, it is our duty, in uniform, to monitor what is happening in the IOR… We keep track of every ship that enters the region, whether it is Chinese or belongs to other navies or merchant fleets,” he added.
The Great Nicobar Project includes a container port at Galathea Bay, an international airport, a 450 MVA gas-solar power plant and a planned township. The proposed port is around 40 nautical miles from the main east-west shipping route.
Congress Raises Environmental and Tribal Rights Concerns
Meanwhile, the project has also faced criticism over its possible impact on forests and local tribal communities. On September 30, Congress leader Jairam Ramesh accused the Centre of pushing ahead with the Rs 92,000-crore project despite several legal challenges. He also pointed out that its cost had increased from the earlier Rs 72,000 crore.
“The Modi Govt has been bulldozing through the Rs 92,000 crore (revised upward from the earlier Rs 72,000 crore) Great Nicobar Island Project. The various approvals under environment and forest laws have been deeply flawed, and the impact assessment reports have been pre-fixed and are of dubious value,” Ramesh said.
Belgium Deploys Six F-16 Fighter Jets to Lithuania for NATO Air Defence Mission
Ramesh said five petitions filed by citizens and civil society groups were pending before the Calcutta High Court. One of these cases concerns alleged violations of the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and their impact on local tribal communities.
“One faint glimmer of hope is provided by the 5 different petitions filed by public-spirited citizens and civil society groups that are pending in the Calcutta High Court. One of these petitions concerns serious violations of the Forest Rights Act, 2006, which affects the local tribal communities. The final hearing is fixed for Nov 25 and 26, 2026, to which the Modi Govt had agreed,” He said.
Ramesh also criticised the Centre for approaching the Supreme Court to stop the High Court proceedings. In his September statement, he said October 5 was the expected date for the matter to be heard.
“But now in an astonishing U-turn, the Modi Govt wants the Supreme Court to stay all proceedings in the Calcutta High Court. Oct 5, 2026 is the likely date on which this plea will be heard in the Supreme Court,” he said.
The Supreme Court heard the matter on October 5 but declined to stop the Calcutta High Court proceedings. It asked the High Court to make an effort to hear the pending cases on November 25 and 26. The Supreme Court didn’t decide the main environmental and tribal rights issues, which remain before the High Court.
Ramesh also said the Calcutta High Court had accepted the right of a former senior government official to challenge the project. The woman had worked in the Union ministries of Environment, Forests and Climate Change and Tribal Affairs.
“The Calcutta High Court had upheld the right of the petitioner, who has been a very senior official in both the Union Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change and the Union Ministry of Tribal Affairs, to file her challenge. Her right to challenge had been questioned by the Modi Govt, but that had been rejected by the Calcutta High Court. Now the Modi Govt is making the same argument in the Supreme Court, which hopefully will allow the Calcutta High Court to proceed on the matter as scheduled,” he said.
He further accused the Centre of continuing with the project even though the legal cases are still pending.
“The sad fact remains that even though these five petitions are pending in the Calcutta High Court, the Modi Govt is mindlessly going ahead with inflicting this ecological disaster on our country,” he said.

